Are People Still Surprised that Self-Published Books Have Value?

*This post has spoilers.*

The Polygamist, Netflix’s new series about a South African man with three wives and a side chick, is snatching everybody’s edges. Social media can’t stop talking about the drama.

The story follows wealthy businessman Jonasi Gomora and the drama between his wives and his mistress.

Jonasi is a hot mess. As one reviewer put it: “Heโ€™s misogynistic, and abusive and every terrible stereotype of badly behaved men you can think of.”

And the women are just as foolish as they are glamorous.

Joyce is the first wife. Together, they have three children.

Essie is the second wife Jonasi kept hidden from Joyce and everybody else. They also have a daughter together. While he has known Essie the longest (since they were kids), he visits them in secret, and the daughter cannot openly be loved by her father.

To keep Essie hidden, Jonasi’s brother pretends to be her husband the entire time. He basically puts his life on hold to keep up the facade.

Matipa is the side chick, turned third wife, who thought she was the second wife (cause remember, nobody knows Jonasi is married to Essie). Together, they have twin girls.

Also, it was Joyce who recommended Matipa’s upgrade to the status of a wife, hoping it would stop Jonasi from cheating.

Jonasi is not done. He eventually starts dating and having sex with his daughter’s friend, Lindani. It’s the same girl his son has a crush on.

And this is just a basic overview of the story that’s got everybody’s attention.

It’s like an African, more toxic version of Waiting to Exhale.

Author Sue Nyathi (left) wrote The Polygamist, which was adapted into a Netflix supernovela. Jonasi Gomora (right) is the lead character. ยฉ Collage/TAR

What people aren’t talking much about is that the book from which The Polygamist was adapted was first self-published.

Sukoluhle “Sue” Nyathi was born in Bulawayo, a city in southwest Zimbabwe, and self-published her debut novel in 2012 after being rejected by mainstream publishers.

While it took many years to reach your screen, the idea to turn it into a film came as early as 2013, just one year after the book was in print.

It was republished by Pan Macmillan South Africa in 2020, produced by Stained Glass Productions, and acquired by Netflix.

It became one of Netflix’s most-watched non-English series within weeks of its June release, trending across Africa, the Caribbean, and parts of Europe. The story has also started online debates about poly relationships, multiple wives in the Bible, and whether or not Jonasi Gomora was a victim or villain. The author says:

“I just wanted to write a story that would get people talking about the uncomfortable things that, as a society, we tend to shove under the rug,” she said. “People are saying their fathers are like Jonasi, or they could see their moms in some of the women in the story. It just goes to show that, as a society, there is a lot of brokenness and we need healing.”

-Nyathi

Are People Still Surprised Self-Published Books Have Value?

Whenever a self-published book has a breakout moment, people act like it’s an animal they’ve never seen before, and major publishers rush in to claim the title as their own.

That a self-published book (messy as the storyline is) can do so well that it becomes a TV show is not surprising to those of us who already read, write, and enjoy independently published books.

I hope that self-published and Independent authors are encouraged to know that their work is valuable, with or without the validation of larger, mainstream publishers and platforms.

I am interested in reading the book to understand what the original storyline was like and how much, or how little, the adaptation drew from it.

The author notes that the changes didn’t take away from the original storyline.

We shall see…

1 Million Black Readers

I’ve always loved to read, and it was magnified in High School, when my auntie would make us check out no less than two books from the local library every two weeks, or however long we had before we had to return them.

And she wasn’t done there.

She also brought ALDI bags to fill with books, checking out tens of books at a time.

We were the only kids who looked like we had just gone grocery shopping as we came out of the library.

This is why I will always be an advocate for reading. In the words of Malcolm X:

“My alma mater was books, a good library…. I could spend the rest of my life reading, just satisfying my curiosity.”

Which is why I teamed up for an amazing challenge.


The 1 Million Reading Black Books Summer Reading Club aims to encourage a million people to read at least one book written by a Black author this summer!

Joining is easy.

Pledge to read and finish reading a book by a Black author by the end of the summer.

Repost the graphic and tag a friend.

Follow the host @melanatedreader on Instagram for the next steps.

If you are not on Instagram, I still encourage you to participate just by reading at least one book by a Black author this summer.

Let’s read something other than captions and comments!



What I’m currently reading: 
Black Titan: A.G. Gaston and the Making of a Black American Millionaire by Carol Jenkins and Elizabeth Gardner Hines.

AI is Watering Down Your Voice

It’s been a minute since I’ve talked about publishing on this blog. Mostly, I was just tired of giving advice. Still am.

Most of the work is doing the thing. Failing at it. Succeeding at it, and failing again until you find your groove.

Butttttโ€ฆ our latest viral sensations have brought me out of hiding.

Enter AI and Dr. Cheyenne Bryant

These seem like unrelated, separate topics, but stay with me.

Lately, I’ve been noticing tons of creators with social media captions that use the same “It’s not x, it’s y” ChatGPT cadence, including authors.

Why are people who write books using AI to write their social captions? Isn’t being creative like, our literal job?

The “it’s not x, it’s y” cadence sounds like: “It’s not just a meal, it’s an experience.”

The words are also structured a certain way, and it is noticeable for those who know what to look for.

For me, it’s mostly noticeable when someone drastically changes how they write. Since I’m a poet, I compare it to suddenly sounding like a poetic professor. You’ve once been an emperor of typos, and now the words flow neatly on top of one another.

The phrases are very well-written, too well-written for a person who has never written in such a way.

It seems to mimic how professional writers write, except now everyone is doing it.

Suddenly, everyone’s Insta captions and Facebook posts are grammatically correct, inspirational, and profoundly poetic.

It is also profoundly fake.

While it might read pretty, it waters down the writer’s authentic voice.

I’d be remiss not to mention that this is not everyone. There are some fantastic, extraordinary writers out there, and for the record, AI is mimicking the genius of the real brain.

The most tell-tale sign is whether I can sense your personality in your writing, or if instead you just sound like an English teacher when you are not one.

The twist in all of this is that typos will become the new normal. They will signal that the person who wrote the piece is a human who makes mistakes and uses their own mind.

You Sound Just Like Everybody Else

What should be most disturbing is that using chat to write will have you sounding like everyone else in the same way that all those AI flyers look the same.

These flyers are always way too cluttered. There is too much information on them, and they end up drawing attention away from the core message, which is drowned out by so many colors and images.

This leads me to question if people are even trying to make changes to the prompts, templates, or whatever they are using.

As a reminder, Canva still exists and has some great free and paid templates from real graphic artists. For my poetry contest, I hired someone on Fiverr to handle the initial design, then paid for the source file. The source file allows me to go in and edit it into as many versions as I want without paying for them. So far, I have turned two graphics into seven to promote my sponsors and judges. It was the best $20 I’d ever spent.

Ya’ll are watering down your voice and image.

I’ve also been seeing a ton of new self-published books with AI/ChatGPT-generated book covers. I cannot emphasize how strongly I recommend not doing this.

You are likely damaging your author brand and marketing strategy before they even begin.

And this isn’t just my opinion. It’s what readers are saying.

An arts digital marketer and historical fiction/romance author conducted a survey asking readers whether they were interested in reading books with AI-generated art.

84% of the people who took her survey said NO.

Additionally, I have been monitoring the bookish community on Threads, and many readers say they don’t trust books with AI-generated covers.

If your book cover is AI-generated, it’s hard not to wonder if your book was written by ChatGPT, Gemini, or any other artificial intelligence software.

It’s hard not to wonder if you’ve put the hard work in to write or if the computer has done the writing for you.

Consequently, even if you did write the book, it’s challenging for readers to see you as an authentic voice.

The book cover is your first impression. Lose readers there, and they are not reading your book.

Speaking of authenticity, enter Dr. Cheyenne Bryant, the woman currently under fire for the legitimacy of her doctorate and the location of her dissertation.

Dr. Bryant also just published a book that people are saying sounds like it was written by AI.

With twelve 1-2-star Amazon reviews, it is littered with claims of fraud stemming from her latest allegations that she is not a real therapist or psychologist.

More of this in part 2…


Yecheilyah’s Book Reviews – Sick by Christa Wojciechowski

Title: Sick

Author: Christa Wojciechowski

Publisher:ย Blood Bound Books

Genre: Medical Thriller, Psychological Fiction

Published: October 14, 2025

Pages: 282 pages


Susan Branch is in a different kind of prison. She is a prisoner of her husband’s illnesses. From broken bones, surgeries, rashes, and medications she sometimes steals from her job as a medical clerk of a podiatrist, Susan is forced to take care of her ailing husband. John is diagnosed with Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura, a complicated blood disorder, and for Susan, “In sickness and in health” takes on a literal meaning.

“Medications to give, wounds to clean, bed pans to empty, and food to serve.” (pg. 20) Taking care of John has become Susan’s life, going to work her only reprieve before returning to a home where she is locked inside the unsanitary cell of her and John’s bedroom.ย 

As the story unfolds, John begins to feel less like a husband and more like a helpless child trapped in a man’s body. Susan reads to him until her voice cracks, feeds him baby food, hums lullabies meant to soothe infants, and speaks to him like a mother coaxing a toddler to behave, calling him a ‘good boy.’

John pouts, sulks, and whines when things don’t go his way, and Susan seems to shrink a little more each day, her life orbiting entirely around John’s frailty. She is no longer a wife, not even quite a woman anymore, but a nurse, a mother, a prisoner in her own home.

My version of John and Susan using Chatgpt Sora, lol.

As the story progresses, we learn more about John Branch’s history, his upbringing, and his perspective on life. Readers gain insight into how John Branche’s response to the trauma of his childhood has influenced his adult decisions. When I read this story years ago, I said he was retarded. However, this progeny of old money is not retarded at all. John is quite the mastermind and narcissist with a sophisticated way of manipulating those around him. John does not believe his actions are wrong. He thinks we are all guided by our natural instincts. Speaking of nature, the author plays well with irony and karma.ย 

This story is well-written and fleshed out. The more you read, the more is revealed. Just when you think you’ve figured it out, there are more layers of the onion to peel off. The author keeps you on your toes, and the more I read, the more I found myself imagining watching an episode of American Horror Story.

Psychological fiction might just be my new favorite genre. I love twists and things that make me go “Whaatt??”

There are parts of the story where I felt sorry for Susan, and parts when I didn’t. Is she a prisoner, or is she also sick? Or, as John would say, are we all just a little sick?

ย 

“Most of us hide it so deep within that we can convince ourselves it doesn’t exist, while it gestates like a mutant embryo. But you can detect it in everyone. You can sniff it out. You can see it in people’s eyes when they think no one is watching them. There are tellsโ€”religion, porn addiction, smoking, or something as innocent as nail biting. Anything to distract themselves from the beast slumbering inside.”

โ€“ John Branch

89707

Ratings

  • Plot Movement / Strength: 5/5
  • Entertainment Factor: 4/5
  • Characterization: 5/5
  • Authenticity / Believable: 5/5
  • Thought Provoking: 5/5

Overall: 5/5

Sick is Available Now on Amazon


My Review Series is Open Again for a Limited Time.

Apply here

Due to the high demand, you must apply based on the instructions provided at the link. Please do not send anything other than what is specified.

IMG_8994

Yecheilyah’s Book Reviews is a reputable review service that features writers from around the world, including both traditionally and independently published authors. We are listed on Kindlepreneur as a top-tier book review blog and on Reedsy as one of their vetted active book blogs that provide insightful, excellent book reviews.

*Books are read in the order they are received.

New: Book Review Directory

Photo by George Milton

I have created a page on the blog listing all the books reviewed so far to make it easier for you to access them.

Browse the directory and meet your next favorite author!

These are the authors whose books received a score of 3* or more. Support the author by purchasing the book if it resonates with you.

If I’ve reviewed your book in the past or will in the future, your review can be found on this list!

Wanna get in?

Apply for a review today by clicking on this link to get started.

But hurry! The 2023 registry is only open for a limited time.

Reading is the Easiest Way to Study Writing

Photo by Christina Morillo

I can tell right away when a book is self-published by a writer who does not read (or does not do it often enough).

No shade to audiobooks, but when I say reading is how we study how to write, I mean reading physical books.

And when I say study, I mean don’t just read the book, but also:

  • Take notes as you read.
  • Highlight important facts or things that catch your attention.
  • Look up the definitions of words you don’t know.
  • Notice the structure of the paragraph, line breaks, and dialogue.

Consider picking up a copy of a physical book at least once a month and reading it through till the end. It will help you to become a better writer.

And if you don’t have time to read at least one book a month, you have no business writing books in the first place.

And don’t try and fake it because your writing will give you away!

If reading is how we study how to write, our writing also displays how much or little we read.

The Power of Reading

Photo by Rahul Sha

I believe reading to be so powerful that it has the capacity to make one wise regardless of whose institution of higher learning the person has or has not attended. In the world of books, it makes no difference whether they completed grade school, high school, or learned to read later in life. That is the capability of the human mind. It is reprogrammable for excellence. The person who spends more time reading than engaging in frivolous activities can become a person of intellect of the highest degree despite their circumstances. Of this, I am sure.

My experience with reading is that it has an unparalleled ability to jolt the mind into action, turning readers into superheroes capable of phonemic awareness, visual and auditory processes, comprehension, and fluency. Nothing would make me happier for this generation than for them to sit down with a book and taste the deliciousness of its knowledge on their tongues. Magic exists in the world of expanded vocabularies, the ability to think critically, analyze, and solve problems. With just one flavorful novel, they, too, can be hooked on the limitless potential of being a well-read person.