In the words of James Baldwin, “If I love you, I have to make you conscious of what you don’t see.”
Here’s the Game:
Once upon a time, when print-on-demand publishing became more popular thanks to companies like Amazon and Lulu, self-published authors discovered a powerful manipulation tactic: they could reach a higher ranking by reducing their ebooks to 99 cents and getting all their friends to buy them, skyrocketing their books to the #1 spot.
And before you knew it, tons of Self-Published books, both excellently written and mediocre alike, hit the Amazon Best Sellers List. Some authors even put the sticker on their covers.
It was an exciting time…
…for a few minutes.
Most of these authors stayed at #1 for a maximum of a few hours.
Over time, their book sales continued to plummet until the next book, where they repeated this strategy: setting the price to 99 cents and telling all their friends to buy it.
The problem with this is it caused many Self-Published authors to lust after that pretty orange tag, even if it only lasted for a few minutes.
They’d refresh their browsers repeatedly to see where the numbers are.
When I first put I am Soul on preorder at 99 cents in 2017, it was #7 on Amazon’s Best Sellers list.
But I had only sold five preorders!
Chile, my bank account was dryer than a Popeye’s biscuit.
It looked good on the outside, though, and I was technically a bestseller on paper, but I wasn’t making any money.
It wasn’t until I started to shop my books offline and talked to the owners of bookstores that I truly understood how little being an Amazon Best Seller meant to the outside world. I focused my efforts on getting my name out there and increasing my reviews, and this helped me to become an Amazon Best Seller the organic way.
I was also selling out of brick and mortar bookstores and I didn’t have to beg my family and friends to make it happen.
Back to the Story…
The problem with getting all your friends to buy your book is once they’ve bought their copies, the book stops selling.
And that’s what happened to these authors. Unlike traditionally published authors or Indie Authors who focused on other methods and reached the bestsellers through sales, the self-publishers who used the tactic couldn’t maintain the momentum. In a matter of hours, their orange tags were gone.
It’s exciting and praise-worthy to make it onto the best sellers list, whether it’s Amazon or USA Today. However, it is not something Self-Published authors should stress themselves over or allow to consume their writing career.
If the bestsellers list is a goal, authors should strive to do it more authentically. Instead of trying to manipulate the algorithm, focus on selling the book to your target audience, getting early reviews, offering sneak peeks, running Ads, book signings, book tours (virtual or in-person), speaking, and a host of other creative ways to get the word out about your book.
Click here for More Indie Author Basics
The PBS Blog 
Absolutely. Speaking from personal experience, the first time I saw the #1 status, I was like whatever…it’ll go away in a few hours. I didn’t take it seriously (that or top seller), until I saw it sway back and forth over a few weeks. You’re absolutely right about consistency. That’s what keeps books at the top of whatever list, not begging folks to read 😉
LikeLiked by 3 people
Yes indeed. It’s a great accomplishment, but the consistency will tell us the truth. Amazon’s algorithm is finicky and no one knows what goes into it. But, if we focus on doing the work we won’t have to work so hard for what will naturally come as a result.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’ve not been #1 on any list, but have been in the top 10 on occasion. The top 100 is pretty good considering the number of millions of books on Amazon. I’ve been in the general top several thousand, not in categories, which pleased me.
I agree that it’s far better to get a lower steady position than a flash in the pan.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep. That flash be gone quick too 🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person